High Court Upholds National Tallying But Bars IEBC From Altering Results

HomeNews

High Court Upholds National Tallying But Bars IEBC From Altering Results

The High Court has upheld the national tallying of presidential results, dismissing a bid by Senator Okiya Omtatah to scrap the IEBC exercise ahead of 2027.

EPRA Scraps Ceiling on E-Mobility Tariff, Unlocking Kenya’s EV Expansion
9 Remote Jobs With Median Salaries Above $95,000
Wiper Dismisses DCP’s Push for Sifuna as Kalonzo Meets Gachagua in Nyeri
MP Wamuchomba Wants School Buses Treated “Like a Saint Bus” on Roads
Solar Homes Now Face EPRA Dumping Fines Over Unapproved Grid Feeds

The High Court has dismissed a petition by Busia Senator Okiya Omtatah that sought to scrap the national tallying of presidential election results, in a judgment with major implications for how the 2027 General Election will be run.

Justice Gregory Mutai, delivering his ruling on Tuesday, held that the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) is constitutionally required to tally and verify presidential results at the national level. He, however, made it clear that the commission cannot use that exercise to alter figures already declared and certified at the constituency level.

Senator Omtatah, together with other petitioners, had contended that the constituency is the final point for the tallying, verification, and declaration of presidential results.

They also mounted a challenge against Section 39 of the Elections Act, which provides for the transmission and tallying of presidential results at different levels. In their view, the provision created an extra layer through which the IEBC could re-tally or re-verify results after constituency returning officers had already declared them.

Omtatah argued that the national tallying centre should do no more than collate figures from the 290 constituencies before the IEBC chairperson declares the winner. Allowing a second verification process at the national level, the petitioners maintained, could erode the finality of constituency results.

“The petitioner asserts that the introduction of this redundant verification step creates a contradiction: if the results at the constituency level are final (as per the Constitution), then what exactly is the IEBC verifying at the national tallying centre?” the judgement read in part.

The electoral commission opposed the challenge, maintaining that the national process is anchored in law and exists to verify the accuracy of results and establish whether a presidential candidate has met the constitutional threshold.

In its submissions, the IEBC said national tallying does not confer power to alter constituency results but simply involves checking and aggregating figures received from the constituencies.

The court also heard that the Supreme Court has previously held that the power to verify and tally presidential results at the national tallying centre belongs to the IEBC as a collective body, rather than to its chairperson alone.

In his determination, Justice Mutai declined to invalidate Section 39(1)(cb) of the Elections Act and Regulation 83(2), finding that the national tallying and verification framework is constitutional.

The judge described tallying as the arithmetic aggregation of constituency figures into county and national totals, while verification involves checking whether the aggregated figures correspond with those declared and certified at the constituency level.

“The tally and verify function is accordingly not an unconstitutional intrusion upon the constituency finality,” the judge observed.

While preserving the framework, the court drew firm boundaries. Verification, Justice Mutai stressed, does not hand the commission authority to change individual constituency results.

He explained that confirmation under Regulation 83(2) must be understood as checking whether aggregated figures match those certified by constituency returning officers and meet the constitutional threshold. It does not empower the commission to “add, subtract, multiply, divide, cancel or otherwise revise any individual constituency figures.”

The court declared that presidential results declared and certified at the constituency level are final and may only be challenged before an election court.

The judgement went further to set safeguards for the exercise. Certified Forms 34A and 34B, or their successors, displayed at constituency tallying centres are to serve as the primary reference documents whenever national results are aggregated.

National verification must be undertaken collectively by the IEBC, with all commissioners taking part and having access to the underlying data. Candidates’ agents and observers should also enjoy real-time access to the same data available to the commission during the national tallying and verification exercise.

Where electronically transmitted results differ from physically delivered records, the commission was directed to document the discrepancy, explain how it was resolved, and make the record public by the time the final presidential result is declared.

The verdict keeps the national tallying framework intact while clarifying that the exercise is limited to the aggregation and verification of constituency results ahead of the 2027 General Election.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the High Court scrap the national tallying of presidential results?

No. Justice Gregory Mutai dismissed the petition by Busia Senator Okiya Omtatah and upheld the national tallying and verification framework as constitutional.

Can the IEBC change constituency results during national tallying?

No. The court held that verification does not give the commission power to add, subtract, cancel, or otherwise revise individual constituency figures. Results declared and certified at the constituency level are final.

Which legal provisions were challenged?

The petitioners challenged Section 39 of the Elections Act and Regulation 83(2), but the court declined to invalidate them.

Who exercises the power to tally and verify nationally?

The IEBC as a collective body. The court ordered that all commissioners participate and have access to the underlying data, consistent with earlier Supreme Court precedent.

What documents will guide the national tally?

Certified Forms 34A and 34B, or their successors, displayed at constituency tallying centres will be the primary reference documents when national results are aggregated.

What happens if transmitted results differ from physical records?

The IEBC must document the discrepancy, explain how it was resolved, and make the record public by the time the final presidential result is declared.

With the ruling, the road to the 2027 polls now has greater clarity: constituencies declare final results, and the national tallying centre simply confirms the arithmetic before the winner is announced.